Genealogy Record For
Katie Stickel - (Mark's 3rd cousin, 1x removed)
Katherine Elizabeth Stickel (Slaughter) (01/31/1767-11/14/1842)
  • Spouse: Frederick Slaughter (ABT 1765 - 5 OCT 1858) B:Pennsylvania, DEATH: Belmont, Noble, Ohio, USA)
  • Children:
    1. Daughter: Mary Susan Slaughter (Kendall) (JAN 1789 - 19 JAN 1885) B:Virginia, USA, D:Center, Guernsey Co., Ohio, USA, Married Zebedee Kendall (1784-1871) and they had 10 children )
    2. Daughter: Matilda Dolly Ann Slaughter (Shamblen) (1791 - 1870) B:Virginia, USA, D:Henry Co., Iowa, USA, Married Caleb Shamblen (1794-1825)
      on 25 Mar 1825 in Guernsey Co., Ohio, and they had 5 children)
    3. Son: Frederick Slaugher (Abt 1795 - 29 Sep 1835) B:Virginia, USA, D:Salesville, Guernsey, Ohio, USA, Married Unknown? and they had 4 children)
    4. Son: Philip H Slaughter (1796 - 1784) B:Virginia, USA, D:Glenwood, Mills Co., Iowa, USA, Married Lucinda Nichols Shamblin (1789-1851) and they had 11 children,
      then married Ruana Lutz (1819-1876) and they had 4 children)
    5. Daughter: Catherine Slaughter (Erton) (hidden)
    6. Daughter: Elizabeth Slaughter (Wilson) (1798 - 6 Sep 1846) B:Virginia, D:Guernsey Co., Ohio, USA, Married Jeremiah Wilson (1800-1850) and they had 9 children)
    7. Daughter: Margaret Slaughter (1798 - ?) B:Guernsey Co., Ohio, USA, Married John Smith (1798 - ?) on 9 Mar 1828 in Guernsey, Ohio and they had no children)
    8. Son: Henry Slaughter (31 Dec 1801 - 14 Jan 1864) B:Virginia, USA, D:Colfax, Clinton Co., Indiana, USA, Married Rebecca Hurst (1829 - 1869)
      on 17 Sep 1826 in Guernsey Co., Ohio and they had 4 children)
    9. Daughter: Ann Slaughter (Dillehay) (1804 - 1840) B:Guernsey Co., Ohio, USA, D:Henry Co., Ohio, USA, Married Benjamin Dellehay (1802-1879)
      and thy had one daughter - Caroline Dellehay (Armstrong))
    10. Daughter: Eva Slaughter (Lanham) (2 Apr 1805 - 5 Apr 1895) B:Virginia, USA, D:Winconsin, USA, Married John Lanham (1801 - 1884) on
      27 Mar 1823 in Guernsey Co., Ohio, and they had 8 children)
  • Parents
    1. Father: (Henry) Heinrich Stickel, I (1740-1820)
    2. Mother: Anna / Mary McCaslen (1743 - 1820) D:Virginia)
  • Siblings
    1. Brother: George Stickle, I (02/17/1765-05/18/1857)
    2. Brother: Henry George? Stickle, II (02/17/1768-05/18/1857)
    3. Sister: Anna Maria Mary Polly Stickel (JULY 31, 1772 - AFT. 1822) B:Loudoun, Virginia, USA, Married Unknown Smith (1767 - ?) and they had no children)
    4. Sister: (Caty/Katrina) Anna Catharina Stickle (Marshall) (1775-After 1860)
    5. Sister: Phoebe Stickel (Myers) (07/23/1791-09/02/1885)
    6. Sister: Sophia Stickle (Ross) (1805 - AFT. 1860) B&D:Virginia, Married William Ross (1805-1860) on 2 Sep 1830 in Frederick, Virginia and they had three children)
Katherine's Personal Information
Born in Unknown City/Co., Maryland (MD), USA on Saturday, January 31, 1767
Died in Guernsey County, Ohio, USA on Monday, November 14, 1842 (Age 76)
Cemetery: Green Hill Cemetery in Berryville, Clark Co., Virginia (VA), USA
Burial: 30 APR 2003
Marriage to:
    Frederick Slaughter (ABT 1765 - 5 OCT 1858) B:Pennsylvania, DEATH: Belmont, Noble, Ohio, USA) on Saturday, January 1, 1785 (Age 18)
     - in Unknown City/Co., Virginia (VA), USA
     - About 1785
Comments: The following is from Jonathan Long's Ancestry.com Account

Identity of Frederick Slaughter's wife: There are a couple of at least superficially
conflicting sources regarding the identify of Frederick's wife. First, we have
the D.A.R. application membership by a descendant (through son Philip), who
gave her name as Katherine Stigler (no dates). Second, descendants of the line
through Elizabeth Slaughter, wife of Jeremiah Wilson, identified her name as
Elizabeth (likely she was named after her mother). Furthermore, Elizabeth Slaughter
is buried in Guernsey County Ohio, born with the date above and died as shown
above. This is shortly before Frederick Slaughter was baptized in the Salem Baptist
Church. He is shown singly at the time of the baptism. Jeremiah and presumably his
wife Elizabeth were also members of the church. However, there is no other entry
showing Frederick with a wife, so presumably he was a widower after Elizabeth died in 1842.

Because the sources of the information are all related to the same man (and DNA
has shown that they are the same family), there is no particular reason to choose
one over the other. A more logical explanation is that Katherine was the first, formal
name, and Elizabeth was a second, more commonly used name. For now, I assume
that her maiden name was some variant of Stiegler, which appears to have been a more
typical spelling for Pennsylvania Dutch of that family name.

An alternative explanation is that there were two wives, but there is no evidence from
the family structure (or any records) to suggest that there were two. And one woman
born in 1767 could easily account for the 18 years of child bearing needed to produce all
the known children.

Another explanation is that one of the descendants' was confused in naming the wife of
a different Frederick Slaughter, for example, the individual I have identified as Frederick
Jr. in this tree. Or that the were two elder Frederick Slaughters, including one claimed
to have been born in 1743 in Saxony. I have commented on that claim in my entry for
Frederick (husband of this entry).

In the meantime, I am continue to pursuing new leads by reviewing the full D.A.R.
record and analyzing DNA evidence to test my hypotheses.

New Autosomal DNA evidence combined with tax records suggest that Katherine Elizabeth
was a daughter of Henry Stickel/Stickle of Loudoun county, VA (see Message Boards).
Specifically, we have a triangulated DNA segment shared among her descendants
and descendants of Henry's son George. We also have hundreds of shared matches,
a large percentage of which can be traced to one family or the other.

DNA Connections - Stickel(s) Line (From Mark's Ancestry.com Account)
Elizabeth's 1st child - Mary Susan - and 4th child - Phillip - and 9th child - Martin -
all have descendants who have had their Autosomal DNA analysed at Ancestry.com -
Henry's connection to the Stickle(s) line is through his father - Henry Stickel

Source: Jonathon Long
Family Lines: Katherine is listed in the following family line report: Stickel(s)
Search this website:
Family Tree Home | The Stickel(s) Website
Comments to Mark Stickels Return to Home Page
Last Modified on: November 12, 2020
Record Created:   November 9, 2020

URL: https://www.Mark.Stickels.org/FamilyTree2/Stickel-KatherineElizabath1767.html